Every restoration owner knows they need Google reviews. What most of them don’t realize is that Google and AI tools judge not only how many reviews you have, but how recently you’ve earned them.
A profile with 500 reviews but no new activity in months will lose visibility to a competitor with 80 reviews and a steady drip of new ones. The algorithm sees one business as active and trusted and the other as stale and possibly slipping.
Recent data and case studies (like the one from Sterling Sky) prove what we’re seeing across dozens of restoration clients:
Review recency directly impacts where you rank in search and how many calls you get.
Here’s what actually happens when your review stream dries up.
The 3-Week Drop: The Early Warning Sign
Three weeks without a new review doesn’t tank your GBP ranking instantly, but it starts a subtle slide:
• Google notices your “velocity” slowed.
• AI systems (like Search Generative Experience responses) start deprioritizing your listing because you don’t appear as currently trusted.
• Your competitors who are consistently earning reviews quietly nudge ahead.
Most owners can’t see this happening, but the dip in discovery impressions begins here.
The 6-Week Decline: Your Visibility Starts Slipping
Six weeks without a fresh review is where the algorithm gets suspicious.
Google’s behavior signals show:
• Reduced map pack exposure
• Fewer “near me” appearances
• Lower click-through on your listing
• Decline in calls despite the same posting or SEO effort
Consumers also feel it. Modern homeowners filter by “Most Recent” and “Newest” before they even read the oldest reviews. When your last review is a month and a half old, confidence drops.
You may still get some calls, but not the volume you should.
The 10-Week Danger Zone: Competitors Begin Overtaking You
At 10 weeks without a review, your listing enters what I call the “rot zone.”
Google asks itself:
Is this business still performing at the same quality level as last year?
And the algorithm answers with:
Probably not.
What we see across multiple restoration operators:
• Rankings fall several positions
• Your listing gets filtered out by proximity-heavy updates
• AI-generated suggestions stop naming your brand
• Call volume drops often 10–30 percent
Meanwhile, your competitor down the street who pulled in just three new reviews this month gets rewarded.
20+ Weeks: Your Review History Becomes Almost Irrelevant
Once you hit 20-plus weeks without a new review, your massive review count means very little.
Google heavily weights recency because it signals:
• Active business
• Reliable service quality
• Current customer satisfaction
When your last review is 5 months old, here’s what happens:
• Your credibility collapses in AI’s eyes
• Your relevance score drops in Google's maps algorithm
• Even branded searches can produce weaker visibility
• Potential customers assume something changed, management, quality, ownership, or performance
We’ve watched businesses with hundreds of reviews get outranked by competitors with 30–40 reviews simply because the competitor’s most recent review was from this week.
In restoration, people don’t shop around.
You’re either visible in the moment or you’re invisible.
The Hard Truth: Google Rewards Consistency, Not History
Local SEO experts have proven it repeatedly:
Fresh, consistent review activity is a stronger ranking signal than total review count.
You could have:
• 600 reviews
• 4.9 star rating
• 10 years of great reputation
But if you haven’t earned a review in months, AI interprets your reputation as outdated.
Your competitor with 80 reviews and consistent recency looks healthier, safer, more relevant.
So What’s the Fix?
You already know, but here it is straight:
• Ask for reviews within 24 hours of service
• Build an internal team contest for review generation
• Send every employee home with a weekly review quota
• Make review collection part of your SOP, not an afterthought
• Measure recency weekly, never let it exceed 30 days
The franchise who masters review velocity will dominate their market in Google Maps, AI search, Local Service Ads, and consumer trust.
Bottom Line
Your business can’t afford to go:
• 3 weeks without a review – minor slippage starts
• 6 weeks – visibility pulls back
• 10 weeks – rankings and calls decline
• 20+ weeks – your profile becomes functionally “stale”
In restoration, attention equals revenue.
Visibility equals calls.
Recency equals trust.
If you aren’t consistently earning reviews, you’re building your business on a sinking foundation.
SML
.png)
.png)